I have started this list not only for myself but for others who want to see what type of magical shops are out there. Many are local stores or run only by an individual. Hopefully, you will find one that you like or if a local store may be near you.
Tools/Supplies (some have blogs attached to them):
https://www.groveandgrotto.com
www.thewitchsheart.co.uk
https://www.originalbotanica.com
http://www.barefootwitcheryshoppe.com
https://www.spellsofmagic.com/shop.html
http://www.divinationsupplies.com
Stationary:
https://www.craftingwitch.com.au
Jewellery (and statuary):
https://www.moonlightmysteries.com
Bookshop:
Welcome
Beeswax candles (and beeswax/honey products):
https://www.parlourofwonders.com/figural-spell-candles
https://www.chicagohoneycoop.com/our-shop
Candles:
https://www.luckymojo.com/mojocatcandles.html
https://www.mothermaggies.com/candles-1
Person with Products/Services (all have a YouTube channel as well):
https://www.thewitchsheart.co.uk
http://www.kelly-annmaddox.com/p/welcome-and-updates_605.html
http://www.joannadevoe.com
Actual store with a website:
http://www.neighbourhoodwitchgeneralstore.com
https://www.enchantmentsincnyc.com
https://www.rockyscrystalsonline.com
http://questbookshop.com
http://www.elementalbooks.ca/index.html
http://www.serendipitysbackyard.ca
Crystal:
https://earthtreasurestoronto.business.site
http://www.therockspa.com
Subscription boxes:
/https://thewitchesbox.com
https://www.whitewitchbox.co.uk
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/trinket-treasurez/?sscid=21k4_17581&
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/witchy1/?x=0&cn=1&pt=search&gs=tarot&pn=1
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/antipodean-witch/?x=0&cn=2&pt=search&gs=tarot&pn=1
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/magickal-provisions/?x=0&cn=3&pt=search&gs=tarot&pn=1
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/box-of-shadows/?x=0&cn=4&pt=search&gs=tarot&pn=1
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/reikirocksandaromas/?x=0&cn=5&pt=search&gs=tarot&pn=1
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/tamed-wild-apothecary/?sscid=21k4_172xf&
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/goddess-provisions/?sscid=21k4_17351&
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/enchantedcrystal/?sscid=21k4_173ap&
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/magickal-folk/?sscid=21k4_174kk&
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/sacred-iseum/?sscid=21k4_174qz&
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/sacred-space-crate/?sscid=21k4_174xu&
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/spiritual-crate/?sscid=21k4_1755m&
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/nine-of-earth/?x=0&cn=7&pt=search&gs=tarot&pn=1
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/crystal-gemstones-shop/?x=0&cn=14&pt=search&gs=tarot&pn=1
https://www.cratejoy.com/subscription-box/chakrabox/?x=0&cn=9&pt=search&gs=incense&pn=1